Commentary for Avodah Zarah 83:19

איתיביה רבי יוסי בן יסיאן אומר מצא צורת דרקון וראשו חתוך ספק עובד כוכבים חתכו ספק ישראל חתכו מותר ודאי ישראל חתכו אסור אמאי תיהוי כעבודת כוכבים שנשתברה מאליה

[R. Yohanan] raised another difficulty against [R. Shimon:] R. Yose b. Yasian says: If he found the figure of a dragon with its head cut off, if there is a doubt whether an idolater or an Israelite cut it off, it is permitted; but if it is certain that an Israelite had cut it off, it is prohibited. But why? Let it be considered the same as an idol which is broken of its own accord!

Explore commentary for Avodah Zarah 83:19. In-depth commentary and analysis from classical Jewish sources.